Buried Treasure

James Bruce • May 2, 2025

This is what Yahweh asks of you, only this: that you act justly, that you love tenderly, that you walk humbly with your God. 


Micah 6:8 informed the activities of a small charity, the Movement for Faith and Justice Today, based at 1B Sydenham Road in central Bristol from 1995 to 2010. Living at 1B in the summer of 2006, I happened to be making heavy work of giving up smoking. I'd just finished praying a novena to St Rita of Cascia, patron saint of impossible cases, when Adrian, a housemate, told me about an incident in a nearby parish. A meeting of the St Vincent de Paul Society was being organised, and someone needed to contact the parish sister. When they tried her mobile phone, one of the digits was wrong. But the person on the other end said they knew 'Sr Mary', as she was their child's godmother, and gave the caller the correct number. It was a God-incidence, and it partly inspired me to successfully kick my habit.


In those days I felt St Patrick was probably originally from Portishead. This belief was unsupported by any evidence, but the general idea wasn't bad. Formidably exhaustive recent scholarship suggests he very likely did come from somewhere near one of the seaside resorts on the Bristol Channel coast. It's no longer safe to assume that attempts to identify his home turf are like pinning the tail on the donkey. 


That isn't to pretend that a thick crust of folklore and mythology hasn't attached itself to Patrick over the centuries. Yet some people might be surprised to learn that modern historians freely accept the authenticity of his two surviving written works. The autobiographical Confessio and the Letter to the soldiers of Coroticus tick all the right boxes in the way they've come down to us, as well as in terms of their style and overall narrative coherence. Crucially, they are also fully in tune with known contemporary events. In other words, they contain everything one could hope to find in the mid-fifth century writings of a successful missionary Bishop of Ireland. According to the Confessio:


"My name is Patrick. I am a sinner, a simple country person, and the least of all believers. I am looked down upon by many. My father was Calpornius. He was a deacon; his father was Potitus, a priest, who lived at Bannavem Taburniae. His home was near there, and that is where I was taken prisoner. I was about sixteen at the time... I was taken into captivity in Ireland, along with thousands of others."


Developing a hypothesis first put forward by author James Hunt in the 1960s, Harry Jelley made the case for Banwell near Weston-Super-Mare. Careful examination of the placename occupies a sizeable chunk of his 1998 book, 'Saint Patrick's Somerset Birthplace'. Jelley also noted that the correct venue had to be in an area of recognised villa settlement and susceptible to seaborne raiding from the west.


Independently, Professor Andrew Breeze catalogued his own reasons 'to locate the villula of Calpornius on the plain north-west of the Mendips in the vicinity of Banwell'. His paper 'St Patrick's Birthplace' was published by the Welsh Journal of Religious History in 2008. After restating his core argument in the English Historical Review in 2013, Breeze appears to have discovered Harry Jelley's work. 'Somerset, Bannaventa Tabernae, and the Dates of St Patrick' appeared in the peer-reviewed Journal for Late Antique Religion and Culture in 2023. The following extract from the opening paragraph is remarkable for its lack of equivocation. 


"When so much on St Patrick is uncertain, it is good to say that one problem is now solved. The local historian Harry Jelley in the 1990s analysed the famous (and notorious) phrase at the beginning of Patrick's Confessio, where he describes his father, 'qui fuit vico Bannavem Taburniae, villulam enim prope habuit, ubi ego capturam dedi': in English: 'who lived at Bannaventa Tabernae, because he had a small estate nearby, where I was taken prisoner.' Jelley identified the saint's home of (emended) Bannaventa Tabernae ('marketplace by a hill and with an inn') as Banwell, a village near Weston-Super-Mare, North Somerset. He later set out the case in a book. The upshot is clear. Patrick came from a prosperous and thoroughly Romanized part of Britain. It had many villas and was close to the civilized amenities of Bath."


Having read Prof Breeze's article online earlier this year, I had the idea of making a pilgrimage to Banwell. My plan would be to take a train on Monday 17th March from Bristol to Weston-Super-Mare. Adrian had moved to Weston a few years before, so we agreed to meet up at Corpus Christi RC Church for mid-morning Mass; though soon afterwards he had to cancel, as his cousin was coming for a rare visit that day. All was not lost however. On Sunday 16th he suggested we meet up in the afternoon, to make what in 2006 we would have called an SVP visit. 


The surname of Corpus Christi's parish priest is uncannily similar to the real name of Yate-born fresco-sprayer Banksy, whose work is derived from that of Parisian artist 'Blek le Rat'. In his homily for St Patrick's Day, Canon Tom Gunning quoted a passage in the Confessio


“...before I was brought low, I was like a stone lying deep in the mud. Then He who is powerful came and in His mercy pulled me out, and lifted me up and placed me on the very top of the wall.”


On the seafront a stone's throw from Corpus Christi is a theme park called 'Pirate Adventureland'. And not many stepping stones in the other direction, a private residence I passed had a row of perennially nodding little figurines in the window, including an Irish leprechaun. Chintzy old stereotypes like these have contributed perhaps to the climate in which it was once said that '...in Patrician studies, no stone has been left unthrown'. Moreover that remark was reportedly made as long ago as 1961. In 1998, Jelley's theory was greeted by a headline in the Glasgow Herald that was jagged and projectile-like in the extreme. 'St Patrick was English, claims author'. No one says Patrick was English. He was Romano-British; or in the patois of the first Angles and Saxons who settled areas remote from Somerset, decades after Patrick was born, Welsh. Incidentally though, since he established the authority of Rome in a land hitherto untouched by imperial rule, it's hard to think of anyone more deserving of the honorific title 'Last of the Romans'. 


Another sight on my walk inland was the forlorn-looking hulk of the passenger ferry 'Bristol Queen', built in Dumbarton on the Clyde in 1938. In 2008 Professor Breeze looked at the contention that Patrick was from the same part of the world. Efforts to make the evidence fit this credo are hampered by the fact that north and north-western Britain were military zones, all but devoid of Roman villas. Patrick also tells us his father was a decurion; a type of town councillor for which no one had any use north of Hadrian's Wall. Furthermore, the relative tranquillity of Patrick's native environment is highlighted in the observation that "despite the chaos of Britain about the year 400, Patrick returned home years later to find his family still there."


Getting lost on the way out of Weston, I didn't reach Banwell until 2pm. In St Andrew's Church I prayed to St Patrick before climbing Wint Hill, where the site of a Roman villa was indicated on a map in my copy of Harry Jelley's book. But I'd been told it was on private land. All I could apparently do therefore was hold my camera above the level of the hedge and try to get one or two lopsided photos. It was then I noticed a gentleman standing on the other side of a nearby wall. Asking him about the villa, he pointed me to a patch of ground in the field where he'd just been walking his dog. I could tramp around among bits of half-submerged masonry, easy to imagine as remnants of late Roman building work. 


There was little time for much else. At 3.15 I caught the bus back to Weston train station, where Adrian was waiting. In his car we discussed other things, as I intended to save the explanation of my Banwell pilgrimage until we'd reached our mutual friend in Bristol. And that was quite interesting. When I showed them the book I had with me, Adrian said that Jelley was his cousin's maiden name.


James Bruce is a pilgrim and writer who raises funds and awareness for school-feeding charity Mary's Meals: http://www.marysmeals.org.uk


By Phil McCarthy June 5, 2025
Registration for day pilgrims to join the 2025 National Walking Pilgrimage of Hope is now open! The Pilgrimage of Hope is a national walking pilgrimage with four main Ways converging at the Cathedral of St Barnabas, Nottingham, on Saturday 13th September 2025, for shared prayer and celebration. The four main Ways start at the Catholic cathedrals in Cardiff, Leeds, Norwich and Southwark, London, and will bless our nations with a Sign of the Cross and with the Gospels. The routes are named after the Evangelists and use established hiking routes and are off road as much as possible. A small group of 4-6 'perpetual pilgrims' will walk the full distance of each Way, and up to 20 day pilgrims will be able to join for day stages. Stretches which are suitable for wheelchairs and buggies have been be identified. There will be opportunities for non-walkers to provide enroute support, hospitality and prayer. There are possible feeder routes to the four main Ways from all the other Catholic cathedrals of England & Wales for keen long-distance walkers, so people from every diocese can organise their own pilgrimages. More information and registration Information about how to support the Pilgrimage with prayer and hospitality and how to register to walk stages as day pilgrims can be found here . Wishing you every blessing and joy during this Jubilee year, as we strive to become ‘pilgrims of hope’. I hope to meet many of you in Nottingham on 13th September. Buen camino! Phil McCarthy, Project Lead
By Colette Joyce /ICN June 4, 2025
A group of 25 pilgrims gathered at the English Martyrs Church by Tower Hill last Thursday morning, Feast of the Ascension, to take part in the Westminster Way Jubilee Year Pilgrimage, led by Westminster Diocese Justice and Peace Co-Ordinator Colette Joyce. At each station we prayed and reflected on saints connected to London and the inspiration they continue to be for us today: St John Houghton and the Carthusian Martyrs of the Reformation, the missionary St Augustine of Canterbury, St Anne Line who sheltered priests and held secret Masses in her home during the Elizabethan persecution, St Erconwald, St Ethelburga and St Etheldreda. We remembered the scholars of the 7th century who brought learning and education to both men and women, and St John Henry Newman whose own spiritual journey of conversion and prophetic sense of the nature of the Church had a profound influence on the 20th century leading up to the Second Vatican Council. From the church we walked past the Tower of London, where so many Catholic martyrs met their fate during the Reformation, stopping to pray at the site of the scaffold where St John Fisher and St Thomas More were executed. Our next stop was Mary Moorfields, the only Catholic Church in the City of London. From here we walked to the Charterhouse, once a Carthusian priory and home to the first martyrs of the Reformation. The Prior, St John Houghton and Companions were hung and quartered for refusing to take the Oath of Supremacy. Watching from his cell window, St Thomas More witnessed the monks being dragged on hurdles from the Tower of London on 4 May 1535. He is said to have admired their courage and faith as they went to their deaths, viewing them as "Cheerfully going to their deaths as bridegrooms going to their marriage." From here we walked to St Etheldreda's, Ely Place, one of the oldest Catholic churches in London. Built around 1250 as the town chapel for the bishops of Ely. After the Reformation It had several owners . For a a time it was used by the Spanish ambassador as a private chapel. During Oliver Cromwell's Commonwealth, it was used as a prison and a hospital. The Rosminians bought St Etheldreda's in 1874 and have restored it beautifully. As we were walking during Laudato Si' Week, pilgrim leader Colette Joyce invited pilgrims to reflect on the flora and fauna of London on our way. London is a surprisingly green city, blessed with around twenty percent tree coverage - which makes it technically a forest! We are especially grateful to the Victorians who planted the ubiquitous London Plane trees which can be found in streets and parks all over the city, while there are more than 400 other species of tree to discover. "The entire material universe speaks of God's love, his boundless affection for us. Soil, water, mountains: everything is, as it were, a caress of God… contemplation of creation allows us to discover in each thing a teaching which God wishes to hand on to us." (Laudato Si', 84-85) After a stop at Corpus Christi Church in Covent Garden - where former parish priest Fr Francis Stanfield wrote Sweet Sacrament Divine and Mgr Ronald Knox preached his famous homilies on the Blessed Sacrament - we made our way down the Strand, past Traflagar Square, through Whitehall, down to Westminster Cathedral. On our arrival, we weary walkers were greeted by the Cathedral Dean, Fr Slawomir WitoĊ„. We ended our pilgrimage with prayers in the Martyrs Chapel and a reflection from Fr Slawomir on the life and witness of St John Southworth, patron saint of clergy in the Diocese of Westminster. The pilgrims received the final stamp in their Pilgrim Passports and a blessing before returning home. Colette Joyce, Westminster Diocese Justice and Peace Co-Ordinator Read more about the Westminster Way: https://westminsterjusticeandpeace.org/2025/06/02/walking-the-westminster-way/ This article was first published on Independent Catholic News: Independent Catholic News Image: Pilgrims at Westminster Cathedral (Archdiocese of Westminster)
By Phil McCarthy June 3, 2025
In this podcast I discuss the psychology of pilgrimage, especially as it relates to visiting First World War battlefields and cemeteries.
By Peter Chisholm May 31, 2025
Pilgrims joined Fr Gerry Walsh tracing St Wulstan’s life and legacy, from Worcester Cathedral to Clifton Cathedral as part of the Catholic Church’s Year of Jubilee, “Pilgrims of Hope” celebrations. Participants explored their faith while journeying through stunning landscapes and historic locations.
By Phil McCarthy May 30, 2025
The Hearts in Search of God project is delighted to be part of the WeBelieve Festival between 25th to 28th July 2025 at Oscott College in Birmingham!
By Eddie Gilmore May 30, 2025
The pilgrimage from La Verna to Assisi and Rome was the last in a series of walks Eddie Gilmore did with his wife, Yim Soon, and being on the Way of Francis, held particular significance for them both.
By Phil McCarthy May 20, 2025
The Hearts in Search of God Spring 2025 Newsletter
By Anne Bailey May 12, 2025
Anne Bailey shares a video of her pilgrimage along the Whiting Way, the Hearts in Search of God pilgrim way for the Diocese of Clifton.
By Vicki Dunstone May 7, 2025
Help families of all faiths and none in the Diocese of Plymouth.
By Phil McCarthy May 6, 2025
Join the Saint Wulstan Southern Way Catholic Pilgrimage from Thursday 22nd May 2025 to Wednesday 28th May, 2025
More Posts