Walking the Three Altars Way

Gerard Bonner • May 07, 2024

A small group of pilgrims walked a trial Three Altars Way pilgrimage in Easter Week 2024. The ‘Hearts in Search of God’ project was an inspiration to explore the idea that each pilgrimage, no matter what the distance travelled, is in each and every step a prayer.


The route connects the altars of the Martyrs’ Chapel Padley, St Michael the Archangel Church, Hathersage and the remains of Holy Trinity Chapel, North Lees. Churches are places where we gather around the altar. As the General Instruction of the Roman Missal says: “The altar on which the Sacrifice of the Cross is made present under sacramental signs is also the table of the Lord to which the People of God are called together to participate in the Mass, as well as the centre of the thanksgiving that is accomplished through the Eucharist.”


In Easter Week there was a theme at each altar site; of the past apparent destruction, to be followed by the joys of resurrection and new life.


  • Padley Chapel’s altar was buried by the Fitzherbert family 1588 to preserve it for the future. It was found 1933 and re-consecrated 1934. The 90th anniversary of that re-consecration is 12 May 2024.
  • St Michael the Archangel’s Church along with its altar, was destroyed 1692 and rose again in the re-build, which was completed in 1806.
  • Holy Trinity Chapel, possibly on the site of a Beauchief Abbey Grange Farm, was likely to have been re-built c 1685 and destroyed in 1692. The altar is likely to still lie n the ruins of the chapel today. 


As part of the Three Altar’s Way Fr Sexton celebrated Mass on the site of its altar. One pilgrim was receiving Holy Communion for only the second time after being received into the Church at the Easter Vigil in St Marie’s Cathedral. Fr. Sexton reminded us that what was most important was commemorating each individual’s personal sacrifices to maintain the Catholic faith in the Hope Valley. We were standing on the shoulders of past local ‘giants’ of the faith:


  • The 13th century Praemonstratensian Canons of Beauchief Abbey, bringing Mass to the Hope Valley.
  • The martyrdoms of the Blesseds Garlick , Ludlam and Simpson on St Mary’s Bridge, Derby in 1588.
  • The deaths in prison of the Fitzherberts, Sir John (1591) and Sir Thomas (1592) as ‘Confessors of the Faith’.
  • The determination of Matilda Fitzherbert (daughter of John), to ensure Mass, continued to be celebrated in the Hope Valley, at Nether Hurst Farm, following her arrest in 1588, and imprisonment in Derby gaol for three years.
  • Sir Richard Fenton, North Lees, (Holy Trinity Chapel) who was arrested in 1588, and after repeated periods of imprisonment and being the spokesman for recusants, jailed in York Castle and died in 1604.
  • Fr William Southworth, the Mission priest of St Michael the Archangel, following the Second Catholic Relief Act 1791, registered the wrecked chapel as a place of Catholic worship. The church was re-built by 1806.
  • Mgr Payne and Canon Busch who led the campaign to purchase and restore Padley Chapel (1929-1933).
  • The determination of Barbara M. Smith to preserve the history of the Catholic faith in the Hope Valley.
  • The commitment of John Rigby, representative of so many other local people over many years, in making the spiritual treasure that is Padley Chapel available to all.


All were remembered and prayed for as ‘Pilgrims of Hope’ in this Year of Prayer 2024, in preparation for the Year of Jubilee 2025.


If you would like to help make Padley Chapel more available to visitors (April-September 2024) please contact, friendsofpadley@hallam-diocese.com


Gerard Bonner

Friends of Padley Chapel

Eastertide 2024


NB This article was first published in the Hallam Bridge, the newsletter of the Diocese of Hallam. It is reproduced here with kind permission of the author.


By Rowan Morton-Gledhill 10 May, 2024
Rowan Morton-Gledhill describes the first pilgrimage for vocations in the Diocese of Leeds, in the footsteps of GK Chesterton and Fr Brown!
By Phil McCarthy 29 Apr, 2024
In this blog, originally published on the website of Together for the Common Good, Phil McCarthy argues for the importance of open church doors.
By John Chenery 16 Apr, 2024
You are invited to join a pilgrimage taster day walk in Sussex for young people organised by the Diocese of Arundel & Brighton Ecumenical Walking Pilgrimage. NB This is not an event for existing A&B walking pilgrims. Rather we want existing pilgrims to encourage a younger generation to take part. The details are as follows: Walk for Young People aged 16 plus Saturday 25th May 2024 Start and finish at St Wilfred's Church, South Rd, Hailsham, BN27 3JG 09.30 Registration 10.00 Start walk 12.30 Prayers/lunch St Pancras, Arlington 14.00 Michelham Priory 16.00 Arrive St Wilfred’s Church Hall 16.30 Prayers and depart Please bring a packed lunch and wear suitable clothes and footwear. For more info email garyobrien4@yahoo.co.u
By Phil McCarthy 15 Apr, 2024
The Holywell Way is a Pilgrim Way for the Diocese of Wrexham from the Cathedral of Our Lady of Sorrows in Wrexham to the National Shrine of St Winefride at Holywell. St Winefride’s Well is believed to be the only British shrine that has a history of uninterrupted pilgrimage from the Middle Ages to the present day. The Way is north from the Cathedral to join the Wat's Dyke Way which then passes through a valley beside the River Alyn to the villages of Caergwrle and Hope. After 10 miles the Pilgrim Way diverges from the Wat's Dyke Way to visit the Church of Our Lady of the Rosary in Buckley, re-joining the Wat’s Dyke Way just over a mile after this. On leaving the village of Sychdyn the Wat's Dyke Way diverts from the line of the Dyke to take in a Celtic hill fort at Rhosesmor. The Pilgrim Way takes a more direct route, but the two paths coincide again shortly before crossing the A55 North Wales Expressway. After this the path follows an impressive section of the Dyke. The Way ends at the Shrine of St Winefride in Holywell, but pilgrims may wish to walk on to Basingwerk Abbey, the ruins of a C12 Cistercian monastery (1.0 miles). This is the start of the North Wales Pilgrim’s Way.
By Phil McCarthy 05 Apr, 2024
Join the Walking as 'Pilgrims of Hope' online Conference!
By LGBT+ Catholics Westminster Pastoral Council 05 Apr, 2024
Details of the Prayer Walk to mark 25 years of Masses for LGBT+ Catholics and their families in the Diocese of Westminster.
By Phil McCarthy 03 Apr, 2024
View the recording of the recent Pilgrims to Rome Conference!
By Phil McCarthy 01 Apr, 2024
The Hearts in Search of God Easter newsletter with details how to register for the upcoming Pilgrims of Hope conference
By Phil McCarthy 15 Mar, 2024
I was delighted to be asked to lead a short walking pilgrimage between Llandaff Cathedral and St David's Metropolitan Cathedral in Cardiff on 14th March 2024.
By Phil McCarthy 13 Mar, 2024
Join the Pilgrims to Rome Virtual Conference!
More Posts
Share by: